Liftworthy
ExploreTrainFeed
Liftworthy

Every exercise ranked by research, by lifters and by results. Find what’s S-tier for your goal, then train it.

Rankings
  • All rankings
  • Add an exercise
  • Build a workout
About
  • How scores work
  • The app
  • Your tiers
Legal
  • Privacy
  • Terms & community rules
General training information, not medical advice. If something hurts, stop and see a professional.
  • Explore
  • Train
  • Feed
  • You
Explore/Swimming/Compare

For swimming

Band Pull-Apart vs Pull-Up

For swimming, pull-up rates well ahead on our research criteria: more carry-over to swimming.

Band pull-apart does more to prevent injuries.

Both are good choices that build different things for swimming, so a plan can use both.

B
#11
of 15
Band Pull-Apart
Band
S
#1
of 15
Pull-Up
Bodyweight
Research score
59
85
Transfer
Fair
Excellent
Injury protection
Strong
Good
Practicality
Excellent
Excellent
See the full swimming ranking
What these mean
Transfer.
How directly it builds the strength, speed and positions your sport needs.
Injury protection.
How well it guards against the injuries that are common in your sport.
Practicality.
How easy it is to learn and to fit around your sport practice.

The research score comes from these, scored by hand from the studies. Lifter scores appear once an exercise has 10 ratings. How scores work

When each one fits

Good reasons to choose band pull-apart

  • You want something easy to learn
  • Staying injury-free is the priority
  • You want to work one muscle on its own

Good reasons to choose pull-up

  • You want the most direct carry-over to swimming
  • You want to train more muscles at once
Band Pull-Apart
Pull-Up
You need
Bands
Pull-up bar
Skill
Easy to learn
Takes some practice
Type
Isolation
Compound
Why they rank where they do

Pull-Up. Pulling strength through the same overhead range as the stroke.

Also compared for

Climbing

Ranking →
  • BBand Pull-Apart#13 of 24
  • SPull-Up#2 of 24

For climbing, pull-up rates well ahead on our research criteria: more carry-over to climbing. Band pull-apart does more to prevent injuries.

Side by side
Transfer
Fair
Excellent
Injury protection
Strong
Good
Practicality
Excellent
Excellent

Questions

Which is better for swimming, band pull-apart or pull-up?

For swimming, pull-up rates well ahead on our research criteria: more carry-over to swimming. Band pull-apart does more to prevent injuries. Both are good choices that build different things for swimming, so a plan can use both.

Is band pull-apart or pull-up easier to learn?

Band pull-apart is easier: it’s easy to learn, while pull-up takes some practice.

Can you do band pull-apart or pull-up at home?

Band pull-apart needs a band, so a home gym covers it. Pull-up needs a pull-up bar, so a home gym covers it.

Which does more to prevent swimming injuries, band pull-apart or pull-up?

Band pull-apart: it rates Strong for injury protection in our research rubric, against Good for pull-up.

More comparisons

  • Band Pull-Apart vs Face Pull
  • Band Pull-Apart vs Incline Y-Raise
  • Band Pull-Apart vs Seated Cable Row
  • Neutral-Grip Pull-Up vs Pull-Up
  • Negative Pull-Up vs Pull-Up
  • Pull-Up vs Weighted Pull-Up
Band Pull-ApartPull-UpBest for swimming